Skip to content

Why The United States Must Choose Between Conservative And Liberal Principles

February 18, 2013

The ongoing ideological war between conservatives and progressives can essentially be boiled down to a disagreement over the proper role of government in the affairs of those under its jurisdiction.  Why are governments created in the first place?  Who is it that governments are designed to serve?

From the conservative point of view the government is an entity which is created and designed with the primary purpose of protecting its constituents from the predatory practices of others. It represents the combined might of all those who created it and is to be employed on those occasions when the interests of all are in jeopardy.  This is to say that it represents an alliance of those who created it with its initial purpose being to ensure the sanctity of the life, liberty and property of all those who fall under its jurisdiction.

In order for such a government to function it must also ensure a measure of peace and tranquility among its members.  Members must therefore agree to recognize and observe the existence of domestic rules and regulations which ensure that the life, liberty or property of each member cannot be forfeited without “due process”.  In other words, the underlying motive for banding together was to protect the members from those who might do them harm.

The opposite premise seems to undergird the progressive argument.  From the liberal point of view it would seem that the primary duty of government is to take the property of some and give that property to others.  If one considers the genesis of all governments, can one really argue in support of such a position?  While it is true that the left has always demanded that wealth be redistributed when it represented the opposition, it reverts to the norm once in power and proceeds to put into place legislation designed to protect the wealth and assets of its constituents, in its case the State.

The point to this little article is not to suggest that we should not help those who are less fortunate, even if those less fortunate are temporarily ourselves, but that the indisputable purpose of any legitimate government is to protect the life, liberty, and property of those it recognizes as its citizens, even if that means protecting its citizens from the government itself.

Thank you.


From → Liberal Lies

  1. Chloe permalink

    Your article caused me to do some minor research. Before government assistance programs came into existence, there were mutual aid societies, not only did they offer the assistance our programs do, but they went further by establishing survival values: “Societies dedicated themselves to the advancement of mutualism, self-reliance, business training, thrift, leadership skills, self-government, self-control, and good moral character. These values, which can fit under the rubric of social capital, reflected a kind of fraternal consensus that cut across such seemingly intractable divisions as race, sex, and income.” ..

    They were also self-policing to prevent the fraud we see with government programs.

    ” James Madison, who declared that “Charity is no part of the legislative duty of the government.” And Ben Franklin once stated, “the best way of doing good to the poor, is not making them easy in poverty, but leading or driving them out of it. ”

    Those societies fell under “Conservative Principles,” not Liberal/Progressive.

    In my way of thinking, Liberalism shouldn’t be used for *social and economic reform* to prevent the Aristocracy from taking the protections away afforded us by the Constitution and BoR. Conservatives should establish societal ethics; Liberals should protect them; Mutual Aid Societies should fill the gaps… in a perfect world.

    • Thank’s for the additional information and I agree with you analysis.

      Even in the mutual societies II doubt any were set up to take from the other members.

      Thanks again.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Stuff White People Like

This blog is devoted to stuff that white people like

The Precinct Project's Blog

Want to really "do something?" Take back the Republican Party precinct by precinct from the ground up.

Health & Family

A healthy balance of the mind, body and spirit


News, data and insight about the powerful forces that shape the world.


Issues of Interest

GOATMILK: An intellectual playground

The Best Blog in the History of the Whole Wide World


A Classical Liberal Blog on Political Science, Economics, Philosophy, Law, and More

A Philosopher's Take

A group of bloggers discussing philosophical ideas as well as the profession of philosophy

Fabius Maximus website

Breathing on the embers of a dying Republic.

The Return of the Modern Philosopher

Deep Thoughts from the Shallow End of the Pool

Potomac Tea Party Report

News and views about Tea Party issues in Maryland and surrounding states

Fake Plastic Trees

A blog about the back of the box.

%d bloggers like this: